Tuesday, September 18, 2007

Eenie Meenie Miney Mo – Choosing the Perfect Disney Resort

When I first began vacationing at Disney it was an absolutely excruciating process for me to pick the perfect resort. I wanted my choice to be so special, with everything just right. I wavered between one resort and the other. Should I spend the extra money to be on the monorail or just use Disney bus transportation to the theme parks? If I stayed at a monorail serviced resort should I pick the Contemporary, the Grand Floridian, or the Polynesian? Did I want to be in the Epcot area or the Magic Kingdom area? Which is better, the Yacht or the Beach Club? How about the Swan and Dolphin? The list goes on and on. When there are so many good choices, how do you pick the right resort?

Remember that in doing my research for The Luxury Guide to Walt Disney World Resort I’ve had the opportunity to stay at all the deluxe resorts many times over, and I have to admit that the Magic Kingdom area is by far my favorite. No other place gives me the same thrill as a stay around the magical Seven Seas Lagoon. What can be better than a room with a view of Cinderella’s Castle? Of the three monorail-serviced resorts, the Contemporary, the Grand Floridian, and the Polynesian, the Grand Floridian wins for sheer atmosphere. Every evening is special in the glorious Grand Lobby when a pianist rotates with a big band playing all the old-time favorites. It's fun watching brides traipse around and, if you’re lucky, Cinderella’s Coach pulls up to whisk her away. The grounds at the Grand Floridian are lovely with housekeepers parading in Victorian dress and lacy parasols. And now, thank goodness, the guestrooms are in the process of being renovated, something that was much needed. Now if you’re looking for hip guestrooms then the Contemporary is your place, but don’t expect much in the way of beautiful grounds and themed pools. The Polynesian is oozing with romance, the guestrooms are large and comfortable, there are plenty of beaches and a fun pool, but the resort seems to lack the service found at other Disney deluxe resorts.

If you’re a huge Epcot fan, then go for a stay at one of the resorts just outside Epcot’s International Gateway and just a boat ride away from Disney-MGM Studios (soon to be named Disney Hollywood Studios). Choosing between the Yacht and the Beach Club is easy for me – it's the Yacht Club hands down. The Beach Club is just too cutesy, doesn’t have many full-size room balconies, and lacks the sophistication of the Yacht Club. The Beach Club’s only advantage is its closer proximity to Epcot. The Boardwalk Inn is another great choice and the guestrooms should be renovated beginning very soon, but I like the pool (Stormalong Bay) much better at the Yacht and Beach Club . The Swan and Dolphin might be a consideration because of their less expensive room rates, but they come without the Disney magic and with smaller guestrooms.

The Animal Kingdom Lodge and the Wilderness Lodge are in a category of their own, each with their own advantages. Remember that these two properties have smaller guestrooms than the other Disney Deluxe Resorts so think about booking a Deluxe Room here instead with that extra space to spread out and be comfortable. The Wilderness Lodge’s setting on Bay Lake is spectacular surrounded by lovely pine trees. But the Animal Kingdom Lodge’s savanna brimming with exotic animals is pretty special also. I also feel that the Animal Kingdom Lodge is a bit more sophisticated than Wilderness Lodge. As far as easy accesibility to the parks, The Wilderness Lodge is only a boat ride away from the Magic Kingdom, but from the Animal Kingdom you'll need to take a car or bus service to all four theme parks. In short, these two are a toss up in my book. You’ll be happy with either and happier even yet with the less expensive price tag than the other Disney Deluxe Resorts.

If you're considering the Concierge Level at any of these resorts here is the lowdown:

Best Atmosphere: Grand Floridian Royal Palm Club in the main building – you can hear the music and gaze below to the Grand Lobby from the lounge.




Best Décor: The Contemporary’s lounges (there are two: one of the 12th floor and the other on the 14th), both recently redone in a slick, hip style, both with spectacular views of the Magic Kingdom and the Seven Seas Lagoon.






Best Food: While the Grand Floridian’s spread is extensive and very good, I would have to go with either the Wilderness Lodge for it’s hearty choices and excellent homemade cookies, or the Animal Kingdom Lodge where an unusual assortment of great food from Boma is always a surprise.



Worst food: The Contemporary serves what I call a convention spread, a ho-hum assortment often served to groups.

I hope this narrows down the field a bit for you. If you still can’t make up your mind then just eenie meenie miney mo. I’m pretty sure that you’ll love just about any one of them.